"What's the subject?"
That's the question that puzzles Harry Peters the title character of Arthur Miller's
new play. It's a question likely to puzzle audiences who've bought every available ticket
to see the new play starring Peter Falk, and written by the man widely acclaimed as
America's leading playwright with an internationally praised hot young Irish director,
Garry Hynes, at the helm.
Actually it isn't all that complicated. That's provided you can get into the rhythm of
some of the Pinteresque dialogue and accept that the characters you will meet are in the
main player's head. The subject, in a nutshell, is one man's stopover on his final journey
in order to find a meaningful connection between the pleasures and regrets of his past and
the alienation he feels in the present.
Mr. Peters, played by the one and only Peter Falk, was once a glamorous fly boy for Pan
Am in the days when PanAm wasn't an airline but "a calling, a knighthood." He
who flew "into 1000 gorgeous sunsets" and bedded 18 Rockettes in 30 days, (and
marrying one of them), is now concerned with "paddling my canoe with a tennis
racket." As he is uncomfortable in his squeaky new shoes, he is also a frail and
uncomfortable survivor in a world speaking a language in which he can find no subject. Oh,
he looks pretty fit in a tweed coat and hat, but as he quickly explains "I'm older
than everyone I ever knew . . .all my dogs are dead, half a dozen cats, parakeet. . .all
gone. . .probably every woman I ever slept with too except my wife."
It is to meet his wife that he's come to a gloomy and all but abandoned nightclub which
she apparently wants them to buy. But while Harry is not particularly interested in the
club, he knows it's near a shoe store that carries the extra narrow size he wears. It's
after he's bought his new shoes that we meet him, gingerly and squeakily testing them out,
(at first glance they look like white shoes with a pair of those pull-on galoshes). In the
beginning there are only two other people on stage, an omniprescent and apparently
homeless squatter (Erica Bradshaw) who acts as occasional commentator and Calvin (Jeff
Weiss), the proprietor who's eager to make a deal. Calvin is just off-beat enough to make
a little alarm bell go off every time Peters remarks that he seems to resemble a lot of
other people (most particularly, his competitive dead brother). When Adele at one point
dons a nurse's cap it's clear that she too is a fantasy connection to Mr. Peter's final
journey..
Cathy Mae (Kris Carr), a tragic and ghostly vision in sheer white who more than any
other character seems to rouse Mr. Peters from his "terminal indifference", is
the most easily recognizable, (Miller's second wife, Marilyn Monroe). When Cathy Mae makes
her second appearance, and Mr. Peters takes her immobile body into his arms for a fleeting
dance to the accompaniment of "It Was Just One Of Those Things" and flickering
lights, darned if it doesn't take you as well as Peters back to another time and place.
Alas, the dancing Peters' cry "The flat broad belly, the spring of thighs, how the
fire flares up just before it dies!" is Arthur Miller in one of his more melodramatic
moments of poetic excess. Fortunately, the play is full of more memorable language.
Also wrested from Harry Peter's head and onto the stage is the manic shoe store
proprietor (Daniel Oreskes) searching for his missing wife, (Cathy Mae), and two "new
age" emissaries -- a young pregnant girl Rose (Tari Signor) who might be Mr. Peter's
lost daughter and her musician-composer friend Leonard (Alan Moses) whose anxiety about
his laundry is fraught with symbolic anxiety. Anne Jackson as Peters' wife bounces in last
-- brisk and bright and sharp -- from pillbox hat to high-heeled shoes (shades of Mr.
Miller's current and accomplished wife, photographer Inge Morath?). But Charlotte's
briskness fails to pull Mr. Peters' out of his somnolent daze and she quickly withdraws to
the long banquette -- (a dark and dreary red in sharp contrast to Jackson's bright
orange-red outfit) -- alongside, but apart from and unconnected to the other ghost
characters. The movement to that banquette turns the nightclub itself into yet another
subject, a metaphor for times past and a gateway to oblivion?
Don't expect a big bang of sumup insights when Mr. Peters has finished rummaging
through the memory box of his mind. This is a serio-comic fantasia. There is
a conclusion of sorts, or, as Mr. Peters would have it, a subject.
While Harry Peters who is no longer capable of being moved by anything and has a deep
down feeling of always seeming "on the verge of tears" is not exactly a poster
boy for the golden years, Peter Falk does makes the most of the many quotable laugh lines
Mr. Miller provides. He also has the benefit of excellent support by the rest of the cast.
Jeff Weiss is particularly strong as the enigmatic club proprietor, as is Anne Jackson in
her brief and almost last-minute appearance. The lovely Tari Signor blossoms true to the
name of the character she portrays.
As for Ms. Hynes' direction, she has created such an evocative replica of a seedy
nightclub that the much talked about but never seen glories of its powder room somehow
rise sharply in our mind's eye. She is also to be commended for tightning what began as
two hours with intermission to an intermissionless hour and a half thus downplaying the
tendency to have the play's comedic and poetic strengths sound like a long kvetch
about "death's twilight."
In the words of Mr. Falk's famous alter ego, "Oh. Just one more thing--"
If Peters isn't the role model you'd chose for your days "in the yellow leaf"
just switch connections and think of the playwright's own current journey . Unlike Harry
Peters he remains very much a contender. His 82nd year has brought him a life time
achievement award, a year as playwright in residence at the Signature, and the embrace of
two of the best young directors working in the theater (Ms. Hynes and Michael Mayer who
gave the 1950s naturalistic A View From the Bridge, enough distinctive now
freshness to propel it from a limited run at the Roundabout to a second opening on
Broadway. And so, while the Grim Reaper will eventually catch up with Arthur Miller, as
well as Harry Peters . . . to all of of us, Mr. Miller is not sitting in a rocking chair
waiting for his arrival but has instead made integral to the subject that's at the basis
of every other subject.